Marilyn Monroe has been named the greatest movie star of all time by Variety, but the magazine’s 100-person ranking has drawn attention to the absence of African performers, with eight Black stars and one Indian actor making the list.
The ranking, published on 18 November, was compiled by five critics: Owen Gleiberman, Guy Lodge, Daniel D’Addario, Alison Herman and Aramide Tinubu.
The critics said they were searching for “a magic zone where talent and luminescence fuse”, while acknowledging that not every movie star is a great actor and not every great actor is a movie star.
Start tomorrow informed
Save your place for the morning brief. We’ll start emailing when delivery goes live.
Free. Confirm by email. Unsubscribe anytime.
Monroe occupies the top position, ahead of Humphrey Bogart in second place and Charlie Chaplin in third. Jack Nicholson is fourth, while Katharine Hepburn takes fifth place.
Sidney Poitier is sixth, followed by Marlon Brando, Tom Cruise, Toshiro Mifune and Barbra Streisand to complete the top 10.
For African readers, however, one of the most striking features of the ranking is the absence of performers from the continent.
Eight Black performers feature in the list: Poitier at sixth, Denzel Washington at 20th, Pam Grier at 75th, Morgan Freeman at 82nd, Whoopi Goldberg at 87th, Eddie Murphy at 96th, Will Smith at 66th and Dorothy Dandridge at 69th.
Poitier, whom the magazine describes as Bahamian-bred, is the highest-ranked Black performer. Washington follows at 20th.
India has one representative, Shah Rukh Khan, who is placed 92nd. The critics note his record of appearing in more than 90 films over four decades. Bruce Lee, ranked 53rd, also features.
The absence of an African performer means the ranking has no representation from Nollywood or the continent’s wider film industries. While the list includes stars from different parts of the world, none of its 100 entries is identified as an actor from Africa.
The rankings have also generated debate over the placement of several performers.
Divine is ranked 79th, ahead of Eddie Murphy and Sylvester Stallone, who occupies 99th place. Zendaya is 98th, Timothée Chalamet 86th and Robert Pattinson 83rd.
Other notable positions include Orson Welles at 62nd and the Marx Brothers at 55th. Tom Hanks is 17th, Julia Roberts 13th, while Denzel Washington is the second-highest-ranked Black performer.
Some readers questioned the omission of Indian actor Amitabh Bachchan, while others expressed disappointment that Mary Pickford, Gene Hackman, Sandra Bullock and Bruce Willis were not included.
One commenter also questioned why Roberts was ranked above Meryl Streep, who came in at 27th.
The magazine acknowledged that its choices were influenced by personal judgement, describing the exercise as one shaped by “heart and gut feeling” as much as logic.
That subjectivity may explain some of the disputed placements, but the absence of an African name raises a broader question about the global reach of the ranking and the recognition given to stars from the continent.
The 100 greatest movie stars of all time
The following is the complete ranking published by Variety, from number 100 to number one.
100
Henry Fonda
99
Sylvester Stallone
98
Zendaya
97
Alain Delon
96
Eddie Murphy
95
Philip Seymour Hoffman
94
Emma Stone
93
Joaquin Phoenix
92
Shah Rukh Khan
91
Kristen Stewart
90
Lauren Bacall
89
Nicolas Cage
88
Lillian Gish
87
Whoopi Goldberg
86
Timothée Chalamet
85
Burt Reynolds
84
Kate Winslet
83
Robert Pattinson
82
Morgan Freeman
81
Liv Ullmann
80
Sean Penn
79
Divine
78
Gregory Peck
77
Ryan Gosling
76
Burt Lancaster
75
Pam Grier
74
Robert Downey Jr.
73
Barbara Stanwyck
72
Nicole Kidman
71
Matt Damon
70
Jack Lemmon
69
Dorothy Dandridge
68
Daniel Day-Lewis
67
Robert Mitchum
66
Will Smith
65
Michael Caine
64
Russell Crowe
63
Faye Dunaway
62
Orson Welles
61
Elvis Presley
60
Sophia Loren
59
Arnold Schwarzenegger
58
Gene Kelly
57
Jodie Foster
56
John Travolta
55
The Marx Brothers
54
Robert De Niro
53
Bruce Lee
52
Joan Crawford
51
Kirk Douglas
50
Diane Keaton
49
Marcello Mastroianni
48
Warren Beatty
47
Shirley Temple
46
Robin Williams
45
Steve McQueen
44
Julie Andrews
43
Marlene Dietrich
42
Dustin Hoffman
41
Fred Astaire and Ginger Rogers
40
Jane Fonda
39
Rudolph Valentino
38
Leonardo DiCaprio
37
Catherine Deneuve
36
James Cagney
35
Vivien Leigh
34
Spencer Tracy
33
Judy Garland
32
Al Pacino
31
Paul Newman
30
Grace Kelly
29
Brad Pitt
28
James Stewart
27
Meryl Streep
26
Audrey Hepburn
25
Harrison Ford
24
Elizabeth Taylor
23
Sean Connery
22
Greta Garbo
21
Robert Redford
20
Denzel Washington
19
John Wayne
18
Ingrid Bergman
17
Tom Hanks
16
Bette Davis
15
Clark Gable
14
James Dean
13
Julia Roberts
12
Cary Grant
11
Clint Eastwood
10
Barbra Streisand
9
Toshiro Mifune
8
Tom Cruise
7
Marlon Brando
6
Sidney Poitier
5
Katharine Hepburn
4
Jack Nicholson
3
Charlie Chaplin
2
Humphrey Bogart
1
Marilyn Monroe

Discussion0