Skip to content
Headlines
HomeOpinionA $100 million settlement won’t clean this river
Nov 19, 20261 min read

A $100 million settlement won’t clean this river

A $100 million settlement won’t clean this river
Galaxy TV · Opinion desk · Lagos

Companies had the right to inquire about which regulations they had allegedly violated. The public has a right to ask questions before the first commercial shipment leaves the Pacific: who approved the sale, who receives payment for the sale, and who pays for repairing any damage that cannot be fixed?

Story reading is not supported in this browser.

Share

Companies had the right to inquire about which regulations they had allegedly violated. The public has a right to ask questions before the first commercial shipment leaves the Pacific: who approved the sale, who receives payment for the sale, and who pays for repairing any damage that cannot be fixed?

The Metals Company (TMC), in a November securities filing, stated that it was anticipating a response from the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA) by mid-December regarding whether NOAA would certify TMC’s application to conduct exploration and subsequent commercial mining of a portion of the Pacific seabed. If NOAA provides such certification, this will allow TMC to proceed with obtaining a permit to mine outside any nation’s jurisdictional limits. Why does the US government have the authority to decide for all nations whether or not this type of activity may occur?

The dispute was centred on the Clarion-Clipperton Zone, an area of the Pacific Ocean in which two subsidiaries of a Canadian-based company have exploration contracts with the International Seabed Authority. Nauru sponsored one subsidiary (Nauru Ocean Resources Inc.), while Tonga sponsored the second subsidiary (Tonga Offshore Mining Ltd.). A third affiliate of the Canadian-based company, TMC USA, requested permission from the US government, pursuant to its own mining laws, to operate in areas that directly overlapped those designated in the international exploration contracts. In response, the International Seabed Authority initiated investigations into compliance issues. Both of the Canadian-based subsidiaries then filed suit against the International Seabed Authority to prevent these investigations.

Start tomorrow informed

Save your place for the morning brief. We’ll start emailing when delivery goes live.

Free. Confirm by email. Unsubscribe anytime.

In Hamburg on July 18, the Seabed Disputes Chamber of the International Tribunal for the Law of the Sea allowed the inquiries to continue. It also ordered the authority to conduct its inquiries and contract extensions using due process; provide the contractors with sufficient information so that they could effectively participate in these proceedings; and work together with the contractors to prevent an escalation of the dispute. Two days later, the council of the authority granted the contractor from Nauru a five-year extension of its exploration contract, but without predetermining what would happen as a result of the inquiry. The July orders did not address the initial claims made against the authority.

The United States has a valid reason to secure dependable sources of essential minerals. However, the US is not a signatory to the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea. Under this convention, the deep seabed located within international waters and the resources contained therein are considered the common heritage of all mankind. NOAA’s thorough review can inform Americans about the potential impact of planned exploration on the oceans; however, it does not allow foreign nations to vote on whether or not collectively owned resources are extracted or give them a say in how the benefits will be distributed.

The White House needs to instruct NOAA to cease issuing commercial permits in international waters while the US pursues a multilateral agreement on environmental safeguards, liability and benefit-sharing. The Senate needs to debate and vote on whether the US will participate in the Law of the Sea Convention, which establishes international rules for the oceans.

The Seabed Authority needs to make public what it does when it has questions about compliance, explain why it makes each inquiry, and provide contractors with an opportunity to respond before making any negative decisions against them. All member states of the Seabed Authority must require that all baseline environmental data be publicly available, that there be independent monitoring of activities being conducted under contract, and that adequate financial mechanisms be in place to enforce liability for environmental damage before allowing contractors to commercially extract resources from the ocean floor. Finally, the communities of the Pacific that have a direct interest in the outcome of the Seabed Authority’s decisions must be provided with a formal avenue to dispute the information on which the Seabed Authority’s decisions are based before those decisions are finalised.

Companies had the right to inquire about which regulations they had allegedly violated. The public has a right to ask questions before the first commercial shipment leaves the Pacific: who approved the sale, who receives payment for the sale, and who pays for repairing any damage that cannot be fixed?

Roka is Managing Partner, Law Firm Victorious Indonesia

Keep the news with you

Read the latest stories and save articles in the Galaxy TV app.

Tags:
F
Fransiscus Nanga Roka
Reporter

Reporting for Galaxy TV from Lagos and Abuja, covering energy and national affairs across Nigeria and West Africa